AIBMS bounces back from pandemic with strong 2022 numbers

AIB Merchant Services, the Irish joint venture between Allied Irish Banks and Fiserv (First Data) reported a strong performance in 2022 with profits up 31%. 

Dublin based AIBS is Ireland’s largest domestic merchant acquirer. It serves all business types, large and small, with lead generation primarily via the bank network. The product portfolio includes Clover and the business competes with Bank of Ireland Payment Acceptance (Global Payments) and Elavon.

 In the UK, AIBMS mainly supplies SMEs through ISO relationships such as Fidelity PaymentCard SaverCardcutters Adelante and Payment Plus. Post-Brexit, AIBMS can no longer serve its British clients from Ireland and has established a UK entity which is expected to receive its payment institution licence during 2023. 

The third leg of the business is internationally focused and high-risk with domain expertise in gambling and gaming. AIBMS can pay out in 18 currencies and offers multi-functional Merchant IDs (MIDs) which greatly simplify multi-currency and multi-channel operations for complex merchants.

The company’s focus in 2022 was “managing merchant charge back risk and negative balance risk” arising from the pandemic and the economic recovery. This was successfully achieved although management report “some inflationary pressures but no slowdown in merchant sales.”

AIBMS does not report payment volume but does disclose gross fee and commission income – the total amount it billed to merchants including interchange and scheme fees. This figure grew 44% to €780m with particularly strong performance in Ireland which remains the company’s largest market. Although merchant service charges grew 41%, revenue from other fees which includes terminal rental was up just 8%. 

Management points to to “economic activity returning to pre Covid-19 levels” and the continued consumer shift from cash to card. Volumes also benefited “substantially from the boarding of large corporate merchants via wholesale independent sales organisations” such as Payzone, the Irish ISO acquired by AIB and Fiserv for €100m in 2019.

Net fee and commission income – after deducting the changes passed through to the card schemes – rose rather more slowly, and was up 16% at €112m. This likely fall in take rate could be due to a growing proportion of enterprise customers in its portfolio or an unfavourable mix of transactions processed by customers on fixed price contracts. Or both.

Operating expenses rose 13% to €57m. Total staff costs were up 16% to €12m. Employee numbers grew from 108 to 135 at an average of €91K each. Credit losses grew 23% to €2.1m or 1.9% of net revenue, modest for a business with a number of high-risk clients. 

Net operating income grew 31% to €62m with operating margin up 7%pts to 55%. 

Unlike Cardnet, Fiserv’s JV with Lloyds Bank in the UK, AIBMS is still not paying a dividend to its parents “due to the potential for chargeback loss events arising” from the pandemic and “the uncertain economic outlook.” However, AIBMS has made a €75m loan to Fiserv at commercial rates.

Strong cost and risk controls boost AIBMS

AIB Merchant Services recovered strongly from the pandemic in 2021 with full year revenues and profits both up on the previous year.

Dublin based AIBMS is a JV between Fiserv and Allied Irish Banks. In Ireland, it is the largest domestic merchant acquirer serving all business types, large and small. Lead generation is primarily via the bank network. In the UK, AIBMS mainly supplies SMEs through ISO relationships such as  Fidelity PaymentCard SaverCardcutters and Payment Plus. Finally, there is a more internationally focused, high-risk business with domain expertise in gambling and gaming. AIBMS can pay out in 18 currencies and offers multi-functional Merchant IDs (MIDs) which greatly simplify multi-currency and multi-channel operations for complex merchants.

Merchant service charges rose 51% to €601m in FY 2021 with other fees (terminal rental, chargeback fees, DCC etc) rising 29% to €40m. Total fee and commission income for the international business rose 82%, in Ireland by 36% and in the UK by 28%. 

Excluding Interchange and scheme fees, net fee and commission income (net revenue) rose 19% to €97m. Management says the improved performance was due to “economic activity returning to pre Covid-19 levels…. And the consumer shift from cash to card.”

Strong cost and risk controls saw total operating expenses up just 2% to €51m. Staff costs rose just 6% and processing costs by 9%. Management had been worried about “merchant chargeback risk and negative balance risk” but credit losses were down from €2.7m to €1.7m. Cautious risk management saw merchant deposits (as protection against future losses) rise 49% at €19.6m.

This operational leverage drove net operating income up 40% to €47m with margins expanding 700bps to 49%. However, AIBMS does not yet feel confident enough in the future to resume dividends to its parents “due to the difficult trading environment and uncertainty.” 

Post Brexit, AIMBS still running on temporary regulatory permissions and is seeking a UK Payment Institution licence to keep trading. The company says this should be live in early 2023.

AIBMS sells Fiserv’s Clover POS products and has added a set of apps from Dublin-based Loylap covering gift cards, loyalty and order ahead. It has also launched a new merchant portal with deep insight capabilities including the ability for merchants to compare their sales with similar businesses located close by. The payment industry has been testing similar products for some time but it’s always proved tricky to get small businesses to access the data often enough to want to pay for it.